If you’re looking for excellent places to eat in Cape May, here’s a curated roundup of top-reviewed spots across different vibes—from casual bites to upscale dinners:
The Lobster House Market Cape May, NJ, United States Iconic dockside seafood spot with fish market, raw bar, take‑out and restaurant, great for fresh catch by the water. Try ordering from the takeout counter and the shellfish counter out back and sit along the marina and watch the day go by. No need for a reservation.
The Ebbitt Room Cape May, NJ, United States Elegant farm‑to‑table American in the Virginia Hotel—Victorian décor, cocktails, live piano—perfect for date or special occasion.
The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar—one of Cape May’s most beloved and enduring dining gems. Try the almond French toast and Bloody Mary and you'll be in heaven. Waldorf chicken, crab cakes, and seafood specials are delicious.
Beach Plum Farm Kitchen West Cape May, NJ, United States Farm‑to‑table breakfast & lunch on a working farm, seasonal menu, casual al‑fresco dining.
Exit Zero Filling Station Cape May, NJ, United States Quirky converted gas‑station serving creative American fare—from curries to loaded fries—in a fun take‑out‑friendly setting.
A Ca Mia Cape May, NJ, United States Authentic Italian BYO spot, homemade pasta and seafood, cozy and hospitable. Terrific lasagna and seafood pasta. Chicken parmesan is delicious and they have a couple of local wines you can purchase. Save room for dessert and be sure to go in the morning for pastries.
Fish House (Sunset Beach) Cape May, NJ, United States Casual beach‑bar‑style eatery right on Sunset Beach—fish tacos, crab cake sandwiches with sunset views and flag‑lowering ceremony.
More Local Favorites
- Lucky Bones Backwater Grille – Casual waterfront spot with marina views, bar food, seafood, and a lively vibe.(Restaurantji)
- The Bee’s Knees Kitchen & Speakeasy Bar—a stellar Cape May gem that's certainly worth seeking out. Easy to get into and has a great vibe. Try the charcuterie board or some other tapas. Great cocktails at this speakeasy.
- Rusty Nail – A laid-back classic with live music, BBQ, beers, and Adirondack chairs—great for groups.(The Infatuation)
- Washington Inn & Wine Bar – Historic fine dining in a Victorian estate. Renowned for dishes like baked escargot and its elegant ambiance.(Best of NJ)
- The Boiler Room – Go down the stairs at the Congress Hall Hotel and enjoy wood fired pizzas and beer. If you go late enough you might discover a wonderful band playing. If the line is long order takeout and eat the pizzas outside in the garden and order some cocktails.
- Out There Coffee – We love this coffee spot and hope you have the opportunity to try this gem on the other side of the Mall. Worth the morning walk.